The public revelation by fashion commentator Derek Guy, widely known online as “Menswear Guy,” that he has been living in the U.S. as an undocumented immigrant since infancy, has stirred both empathy and controversy, especially after Vice President JD Vance seemingly weighed in with a cryptic and chilling meme response.
What Happened:
In a heartfelt thread on X (formerly Twitter), Derek Guy shared that he was brought to the United States as a baby after his family fled Vietnam following the Tet Offensive. Initially settling in Canada, his family later crossed into the U.S. in search of work, unaware of the immigration implications. Guy acknowledged the murky legality of their border crossing but emphasized his deep-rooted identity as an American, having lived in the country for virtually his entire life.
“My identity and roots are very much based in this country, no different from anyone else,” Guy wrote.
His candid story was timed against the backdrop of increasing immigration sweeps in Los Angeles, which have already triggered widespread protests. His message challenged anti-immigrant narratives, particularly those championed by former President Trump and now echoed by JD Vance, by humanizing the undocumented experience:
“People like me are your neighbours, not MS-13.”
JD Vance's Reaction:
Responding to a wave of users tagging him in the post, Vice President JD Vance replied not with a policy statement, but a GIF of Jack Nicholson nodding ominously — a move widely interpreted as a veiled threat of deportation.
The choice of imagery, combined with Vance’s political stance, was interpreted as hostile and chilling, especially considering the power the Vice President holds. Critics saw it as a disturbing use of internet culture to undermine a vulnerable admission, while supporters of Vance celebrated it as “owning” a critic.
Derek Guy's Clapback:
In his signature dry wit, Guy fired back with a fashion-focused jab:
“I think I can outrun you in these clothes,” he wrote, sharing photos of Vance’s often-criticized suits — a continuation of a long-running, humorous feud in which Guy has mocked Vance’s ill-fitting jackets, clashing ties, and overly tight trousers.
Broader Implications:
-
Immigration: Guy’s story underscores the complex reality of undocumented immigrants who’ve grown up American in all but paperwork. His case resonates especially with DACA-era immigrants, though he’s not confirmed any formal protection under that policy.
-
Politics: Vance’s response illustrates how immigration discourse has become personal and performative in the digital age, with memes and viral jabs replacing nuanced debate.
-
Public perception: The incident has amplified online support for Guy, who many view as brave for going public, while also deepening fears among undocumented people watching the administration's tone grow harsher.
In the culture clash between fashion and politics, this exchange has turned deeply personal, revealing the risks of vulnerability in a climate where meme warfare and policy can dangerously intertwine.
