Why MAGA knives are out for their hero: Trump is to blame for Mamdani's triumph


Donald Trump’s Republican base — the self-styled “MAGA movement” — has erupted in anger after a string of stinging electoral defeats in major US races, including the New York City mayoral election, where Democrat Zohran Mamdani made history as the first Muslim-immigrant to win the post. The losses in New York, Virginia, New Jersey, and California have triggered a wave of infighting among conservatives, with many of Trump’s most loyal supporters now turning their frustration toward him.

The backlash comes amid growing discontent over Trump’s perceived neglect of domestic priorities in favor of foreign policy grandstanding. MAGA figures and conservative influencers have accused the President of drifting from his “America First” agenda and squandering voter goodwill by prioritising overseas issues — particularly his focus on Israel, Ukraine, and Venezuela — while ignoring economic pain at home.

Prominent right-wing voices such as Mike Cernovich, Jack Posobiec, Laura Loomer, and Michael Boyle publicly questioned Trump’s leadership following Tuesday’s results. On X, Cernovich blamed Trump for “spending all year on the Middle East,” saying, “His big donors loved it, the voters did not.” He warned that Trump’s “foreign obsession” had alienated voters struggling with inflation, high fuel prices, and stagnant wages.

Vivek Ramaswamy, the Indian-American Republican who is running for Ohio governor, echoed this criticism in a video message, arguing that the GOP had lost sight of kitchen-table issues. “Lesson one: our side needs to focus on affordability,” Ramaswamy said. “Make the American dream affordable again — energy, housing, healthcare, groceries.” He urged Trump’s team to pivot sharply toward economic relief and household cost concerns before the 2026 midterms.

The frustration has also spread within Republican ranks in Congress. A senior GOP lawmaker told Politico that Trump and Office of Management and Budget director Russell Vought had “crippled the party” with their controversial “pocket rescission” of congressional funds earlier this year, triggering the current government shutdown — now the longest in US history. The shutdown has halted pay for 1.4 million federal workers, grounded flights, and caused nationwide service disruptions.

According to an NBC News poll, a majority of voters now blame Trump and Republicans more than Democrats for the shutdown, further eroding public confidence. The backlash intensified after airlines announced a 10% reduction in domestic routes at major airports due to reduced federal staffing, adding to consumer frustrations.

MAGA-aligned online communities have become particularly hostile since Mamdani’s victory. One verified user, @blesamerica, wrote: “If Trump and the GOP don’t start focusing on America and stop groveling at Netanyahu’s feet, funding foreign wars, and chasing regime change in Venezuela, they’ll lose badly. Mamdani’s win was a backlash against putting Israel first.”

Meanwhile, internal scandals have compounded the GOP’s woes. Jack Posobiec, a leading MAGA influencer, blamed “infighting and stupidity,” citing leaked text messages from White House liaison Paul Ingrassia, who withdrew his nomination after being exposed for racist remarks about Asians and Indians, including a slur directed at Ramaswamy. “Congratulations to everyone who spent the past month arguing about group chats,” conservative commentator Sean Davis of The Federalist quipped sarcastically.

Laura Loomer, a far-right Trump ally, ignited further controversy with a tirade on X, calling Mamdani’s win an “Islamic takeover of America.” She accused the new mayor of plotting to “encourage Muslims to commit political assassinations,” a rhetoric widely condemned by Democrats and mainstream Republicans alike.

Beyond social media outrage, strategists warn that the GOP’s losses signal deep structural problems. Analysts point to voters’ growing fatigue with political theatre and foreign posturing amid rising living costs. Trump’s tariff wars, high fuel prices, and inconsistent economic messaging have undermined his claim to be the champion of “forgotten Americans.”

For the MAGA base, the disillusionment runs deeper — a sense that Trump the candidate, who promised to drain the swamp and restore national pride, has been replaced by Trump the global dealmaker, distracted by foreign alliances and personal ambitions like the Nobel Peace Prize.

The Republican defeats have therefore done more than dent electoral math; they’ve fractured Trump’s coalition, exposed ideological rifts, and emboldened Democrats heading into the 2026 midterms. As one strategist told USA Today, “The GOP didn’t just lose votes — it lost faith. The base that made Trump untouchable is now questioning whether he still represents them.”


 

buttons=(Accept !) days=(20)

Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience. Learn More
Accept !