100 anti-SIR demonstrators are detained by his police in Bengaluru after DKS rallies in Delhi


While Karnataka Chief Minister DK Shivakumar was participating in the Congress-led INDIA bloc’s protest in New Delhi, demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar, police in his own state were taking action against people protesting over the same issue. Confronted with this apparent contradiction, Shivakumar and other Karnataka Congress leaders have promised an investigation into allegations of excessive police force.

On Monday, Bengaluru police detained at least 100 demonstrators who were attempting to march to the Chief Electoral Officer’s (CEO) office to oppose the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls. Students, lawyers and women protesters were allegedly manhandled by Bengaluru City Police. Journalists and photographers covering the demonstration also faced police action.

The contrast was evident: while CM Shivakumar was protesting against the Election Commission of India (ECI) in New Delhi, police in Karnataka were detaining demonstrators opposing the same election body’s SIR exercise.

Amid growing criticism, Shivakumar said on Tuesday that any unnecessary use of force would lead to accountability. Karnataka Home Minister Priyank Kharge also stated that he had directed the police to ensure peaceful demonstrations were not obstructed.

Left-wing student and youth organisations, along with the activist group My Vote, My Right, had organised protests across Karnataka on Monday. They planned marches to the CEO’s office in Bengaluru and to the offices of Deputy Commissioners in other districts. Their demands included Gyanesh Kumar’s resignation and the withdrawal of the SIR exercise.

In Bengaluru, protesters gathered near KR Circle, a short distance from the CEO’s office, intending to submit a memorandum. However, police detained them before they could proceed. Senior journalist and activist Aakar Patel was among those taken into custody.

Several demonstrators, most of them students, were allegedly forced into buses by police personnel, many of whom were dressed in plain clothes. A report in The Times of India said police personnel argued that the protesters would return to the location if they were released.

Addressing a press conference on Monday, Akshay M Hakay, Deputy Commissioner of Police for Bengaluru City Police’s Central Division, said the demonstrators had gathered without permission. He said they were instructed to move to Freedom Park but refused to comply, prompting the police to take them into preventive custody before releasing them.

Hakay maintained that the police had exercised restraint. He described the confrontation between journalists and police personnel as “completely unintentional”, saying it occurred under “straining circumstances”.

[Image]

Karnataka Chief Minister DK Shivakumar and Home Minister Priyank Kharge issued official statements following the police action in Bengaluru on October 12.

JOURNALISTS, PHOTOGRAPHERS ALLEGEDLY MANHANDLED BY KARNATAKA POLICE

The police action on Monday also affected media personnel covering the demonstration. According to The Hindu, journalists were threatened and told to leave the area, while three photographers were allegedly manhandled despite repeatedly identifying themselves as members of the press.

The incident was particularly striking because the Congress at the national level had criticised the BJP-led Centre for deploying heavy security and detaining protesters and journalists. Similar actions were reported in Karnataka, a state governed by the Congress.

In their memorandum to the Karnataka CEO, the protesters said they had lost confidence in the SIR process. They alleged that it could lead to people being deprived of their voting rights, arbitrary removal of names from electoral rolls, procedural lapses and a lack of transparency and accountability.

They also raised questions about the handling of cases involving FIRs registered over the mass submission of Form 7 applications. The protesters asked why Electoral Registration Officers had not filed complaints in these cases.

The organisations called for the immediate scrapping of the SIR exercise, Gyanesh Kumar’s resignation, restoration of the January 2025 electoral rolls and measures to prevent arbitrary deletions during future revisions. They said their demonstrations would continue until the CEC stepped down.

CM DK SHIVAKUMAR SEEKS REPORT, HOME MINISTER KHARGE ISSUES INSTRUCTIONS

Reacting to the incident, Chief Minister Shivakumar said on Monday that he had taken note of the police action against protesters and media personnel. He announced that he had sought a detailed report on the circumstances surrounding the incident.

“If there has been any unnecessary use of force or excess, accountability will follow,” he said.

On Tuesday, the Chief Minister emphasised that the right to peaceful protest must be respected regardless of where a demonstration takes place or whom it targets.

“The right to peaceful protest is fundamental to our democracy. We cannot demand that right for ourselves in Delhi and deny it to others in Bengaluru. Karnataka must hold itself to the democratic standards that we expect from the rest of the country. There will be no double standards,” Shivakumar wrote on X.

He further stated, “Let me be clear: disagreement with the Election Commission, disagreement with my government, or disagreement with me personally does not diminish anyone's right to peacefully express it.”

State Home Minister Priyank Kharge also said he had instructed the police to ensure that peaceful demonstrations were allowed to proceed without disruption.

“The right to peaceful protest is fundamental to our democracy. It must be respected, protected, and never suppressed. I have issued instructions to the police to ensure that no peaceful demonstration is disrupted,” Kharge wrote on X on Tuesday.

“Our responsibility is not merely to maintain law and order, but to create an environment where every citizen can express dissent freely, peacefully, and without fear. In a democracy, peaceful dissent is not a threat to law and order. It is a right that law and order must protect,” he added.

The incident has nevertheless highlighted the contrast between the Congress leadership’s protest against the ECI in New Delhi and the detention of demonstrators opposing the SIR process by police in its Karnataka-ruled state.


 

buttons=(Accept !) days=(20)

Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience. Learn More
Accept !