Indian football icon Bhaichung Bhutia described the much-anticipated friendly between India and Brazil as a “circus”, while criticising the All India Football Federation (AIFF) for overlooking persistent problems in Indian football and instead prioritising Saturday’s high-profile match.
The Brazil game on October 3 was part of a three-match international series that also featured fixtures against Panama and Uruguay, both of whom participated in the 2026 FIFA World Cup. Bhutia acknowledged that a match against Brazil would naturally excite fans and former players, and said he himself would have wanted to play against them. However, he questioned whether arranging such a fixture should be the federation’s priority instead of focusing on the long-term development of Indian football.
“From a player’s or fan’s point of view, yes, everybody would love it. As a player, I would’ve loved to play Brazil,” Bhutia told The Indian Express before the game. He questioned whether the federation’s responsibility was simply to provide players with opportunities to face Brazil or to build the sport in the country over the long term.
Bhutia, who serves on the AIFF executive committee, also raised concerns about the reported cost of bringing Brazil to India, particularly when Indian football and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL) are facing financial difficulties.
He said spending an estimated Rs 50-60 crore on the fixture made little sense for the federation. Bhutia pointed out that the AIFF had recorded a deficit of around Rs 14-16 crore in its previous budget and was actively seeking sponsors, while several I-League and ISL clubs were also struggling financially or shutting down due to a lack of sponsorship.
India had initially been scheduled to participate in the inaugural FIFA ASEAN Cup, where they were drawn alongside Indonesia, Singapore and Malaysia — teams much closer to India’s FIFA ranking of 138. Brazil, meanwhile, were ranked sixth as of Friday.
The AIFF had initially intended to field separate squads for the ASEAN Cup and the Brazil friendly. However, it eventually withdrew from the tournament to focus on the high-profile Brazil fixture, a decision Bhutia strongly disagreed with.
He argued that India should not have sacrificed a competitive tournament where the national team could have played at least three meaningful matches. According to Bhutia, choosing instead to pay a substantial sum for a friendly against Brazil was difficult to justify from the perspective of a football federation.
WHY NOT FOLLOW JAPAN’S MODEL?
Bhutia suggested that Brazil’s involvement in Indian football could have been structured more like Japan’s approach. When the J-League was developing, Japan brought in Brazilian players and coaches, allowing its footballers to learn from Brazil’s creativity while combining those lessons with Japan’s own disciplined style.
He pointed to figures such as Zico, who spent a significant period coaching the Japanese national team, as an example of how Japan benefited from Brazilian football expertise.
Bhutia also criticised the AIFF’s leadership and questioned the direction of Indian football, pointing to India’s decline in the FIFA rankings from the top 100 towards 140 and its failure to qualify for the Asian Cup on merit.
India subsequently endured a heavy defeat in the much-awaited friendly on Saturday, losing 4-0 to Brazil.
