Smriti Mandhana and Harmanpreet Kaur had been at odds about captaincy: Report


It was hardly surprising that Smriti Mandhana was chosen to take over as captain of the Indian women’s cricket team after Harmanpreet Kaur stepped down. However, the bigger question is whether the 30-year-old left-handed batter has received the leadership opportunity too late, considering she is currently India’s standout batter by a considerable margin.

Harmanpreet, who first became India’s captain in 2016, decided to relinquish leadership across formats after a review meeting with the BCCI. The 37-year-old from Moga ended an influential captaincy tenure on a high, having just guided India to their second successive Asian Games gold medal in Japan.

Mandhana was the natural successor to Harmanpreet. Since making her international debut in 2013, the stylish opener has established herself among the world’s top batters and has accumulated more than 10,000 runs across formats.

She has long stood out for her batting ability and has continued to develop her game by adding greater power to her skill set. It was also understood that Mandhana had become increasingly frustrated with the selectors for retaining the existing leadership arrangement even after India ended their long wait for an ICC trophy by winning the ODI World Cup on home soil last year.

In a recent interview, Mandhana indicated that she was prepared to take on the captaincy. After India’s Asian Games triumph, she also stressed that the team should set its sights on winning bigger tournaments. However, between the ODI World Cup triumph and the Asian Games success, India suffered early exits from two consecutive T20 World Cups, prompting questions about the leadership, particularly in the shortest format.

The selectors, however, initially avoided making a change. At the review meeting in Guwahati, chaired by BCCI Secretary Devajit Saikia, Harmanpreet was reportedly made aware that a leadership transition was unavoidable. She ultimately chose to step aside herself.

The captaincy issue had also created tension between Harmanpreet and Mandhana, despite their previously good relationship.

“They were not seeing eye to eye for a while now and that led to an obvious unease in the dressing room,” a team source said.

Following India’s early elimination from the T20 World Cup in the UK earlier this year, former captain Mithali Raj had told PTI that Mandhana should have been elevated to the leadership role two or three years earlier. She had also raised concerns about Harmanpreet’s form and fitness.

Mithali had said she expected Mandhana to be handed the ODI captaincy two or three years earlier and suggested that Mandhana could still lead India in ODIs and Tests, while a younger player such as Shafali Verma could take charge of the T20I side.

The leadership transition has not always been handled smoothly in Indian women’s cricket, despite the team receiving less scrutiny than the men’s side.

When Harmanpreet replaced Mithali as ODI captain after the 2022 World Cup, the relationship between the two senior players had already deteriorated significantly.

That transition contributed to divisions within the team. With Harmanpreet now planning to continue playing for another two or three years, it remains to be seen whether she and Mandhana can put their past differences aside and work together for the team.

India enjoyed dominant campaigns in the recent Asia Cup and Asian Games, although Harmanpreet’s individual performances were below her usual standards. With the pressure on her now focused entirely on her batting, expectations are likely to increase, and she will need a significant improvement in form to remain a key part of the side.


 

buttons=(Accept !) days=(20)

Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience. Learn More
Accept !