Review of Being Heumann: Ruth Madeley in a gripping tale surrounded by Hollywood clichés


During the 1970s, a major battle erupted in the United States over Section 504, a law designed to prevent discrimination against people with disabilities. However, prolonged government delays meant that the protections it promised remained largely inaccessible. In 1977, disability rights activist Judith Heumann and a group of campaigners occupied a federal building in San Francisco for 26 days, refusing to leave until their demands were addressed. Being Heumann recounts this struggle and the woman who helped make it a defining moment in the history of disability rights.

Heumann, who used a wheelchair herself, was not seeking special privileges. Her fight was for the basic right to live with dignity and enjoy the same opportunities as everyone else.

Directed and co-written by Sin Heder, the Apple TV release is adapted from Heumann's 2020 memoir of the same name. The film combines the emotional appeal of an underdog story with the intensity of a political movement, although it occasionally leans towards the sentimentality commonly found in Hollywood biopics.

However, the film offers more than just emotional storytelling. With the struggle for equal rights and representation continuing, Being Heumann remains relevant today. Crucially, it does not encourage audiences to feel sorry for disabled people or portray them merely as victims. Instead, it draws attention to the society around them and asks why social structures so often make their lives more difficult.

The narrative begins in New York in 1972, where Heumann is already campaigning for the implementation of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. The provision was intended to protect people with disabilities from discrimination, but the government repeatedly postponed its implementation, pointing to concerns about costs, time and a lack of clarity about the regulations. Played convincingly by Ruth Madeley, Heumann refuses to accept these bureaucratic explanations. She takes her campaign directly to the Department of Health, Education and Welfare, insisting that disabled people cannot be expected to wait indefinitely for their rights.

The conflict eventually reaches a turning point in San Francisco, where Heumann and fellow activists occupy a federal building for 26 days. This is where the film finds its strongest momentum. What begins as a protest develops into an extraordinary demonstration of collective support, with disabled campaigners receiving backing from gay rights groups and the Black Panthers, a revolutionary political and militant organisation. These sequences carry considerable energy, although the film occasionally slips into the familiar conventions of inspirational dramas.

Heder is particularly effective when she allows the movement's members to take centre stage. She recognises that the story is not simply about one determined individual but an entire community that has grown tired of being told what it can and cannot achieve. The film also acknowledges disagreements within the movement, including differences between deaf activists and campaigners representing other disabilities. These conflicts are significant because they demonstrate that unity does not necessarily mean complete agreement. Building a movement requires difficult negotiations and sustained effort, and the film benefits from recognising this reality.

Madeley is the film's greatest strength. The BAFTA-winning British actor, who has spina bifida, a birth condition in which the spine and spinal cord do not develop completely during pregnancy, is also an advocate for disability rights. She brings a compelling combination of wit, determination, impatience and vulnerability to her portrayal of Heumann.

Rather than presenting her as a flawless hero or an inspirational symbol, Madeley portrays Judy as stubborn, humorous, occasionally challenging and unwilling to tolerate condescension. Her performance is particularly refreshing because she allows Heumann to emerge as an individual before presenting her as an activist. That distinction makes a difference.

The inclusion of several disabled actors also lends the film a sense of authenticity. Madeline Delp, who uses a wheelchair, portrays fellow campaigner Kitty Cone, while the wider cast brings a convincing quality to discussions about accessibility, independence and dignity. The screenplay is also notably open about the sexuality, relationships and everyday aspirations of disabled people. The characters are not defined solely by their activism or physical conditions. Like anyone else, they have friendships, differences of opinion, ambitions and romantic relationships.

The film is less effective in its depiction of those holding positions of power. Mark Ruffalo portrays health secretary Joseph Califano, who eventually agrees to sign Section 504, securing a hard-fought victory for the protesters. Although Ruffalo brings his familiar understated charm to the role, Califano appears more inconvenienced by the demonstrators than actively opposed to their demands.

The narrative also gives limited attention to some of the government's more aggressive methods, including attempts to force protesters to abandon their occupation by depriving them of food. This omission is disappointing, particularly because much of the film otherwise captures the difficulties and sacrifices involved in the campaign.

A few other elements rely on familiar biopic conventions. Dylan O'Brien plays television journalist Evan White, while Jon Beavers appears as Heumann's friend and supporter Jim Pechin. The film introduces a romantic angle to their relationship, a creative decision that feels largely unnecessary. Heder also occasionally arranges emotional moments a little too neatly. Rather than relying on conventional Hollywood sentiment, the film could have allowed the extraordinary real-life events to carry more of their own emotional weight.

Nevertheless, these shortcomings do not diminish the film's achievements. Four years after the 2021 comedy-drama CODA, Heder returns to a story centred on disability, this time bringing greater political urgency and anger to the subject. While her Oscar-winning film offered a gentler family drama, Being Heumann takes a more confrontational approach, encouraging audiences to move beyond sympathy and think about accountability.

Ultimately, Being Heumann is a moving and energetic portrayal of a landmark disability rights campaign. Although its occasional reliance on Hollywood conventions softens some of the sharper aspects of the story, it remains a powerful account of a struggle that deserved an even more uncompromising treatment.


 

buttons=(Accept !) days=(20)

Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience. Learn More
Accept !