Director Nitesh Tiwari has defended his decision to portray Sai Pallavi’s Sita as a warrior in Ramayana: Rise of a Legend. The depiction, which features Sita handling weapons and participating in action sequences, has sparked mixed reactions, with some viewers supporting the creative choice while others have criticised it.
Veteran actor Mukesh Khanna is among its critics, arguing that the portrayal strays from Valmiki’s Ramayana. Tiwari, however, has pointed to texts such as the Sanskrit Adbhuta Ramayana and the 15th-century Odia Bilanka Ramayana, which describe Sita as a warrior and a manifestation of cosmic Shakti.
Speaking to The Federal, Tiwari said Sita’s story should not be understood solely through her ability to endure suffering. He noted that different versions of the epic offer varied interpretations of its characters, including accounts that portray Sita as possessing extraordinary power.
“These tellings offer a rather different image of Sita: not merely a figure of endurance but an active warrior and an embodiment of cosmic Shakti,” the director said.
He also cited an episode in which Sita takes on a fierce form and battles a demon while Rama is incapacitated. “In these versions, she assumes the fierce form of Mahakali and slays Sahasra Ravana, the thousand-headed demon king, when Rama is incapacitated,” he added.
Tiwari maintained that this depiction was not simply a contemporary feminist interpretation. He said such portrayals have been part of India's diverse retellings of the epic for centuries and that his adaptation draws upon this established tradition rather than introducing something entirely new.
Mukesh Khanna objects to the action sequence
Khanna criticised Tiwari’s adaptation in a vlog discussing the controversy surrounding the film. Accusing the filmmakers of modifying a revered text, he said, “Stop putting your own narrative into Valmiki’s Ramayana. You should be ashamed.”
Commenting on the action sequence, the 68-year-old actor asked, “Can you imagine Sita Mata fighting like the Rani of Jhansi or like present-day heroines who become macho? I have read Valmiki’s Ramayana. Nowhere is it written that Sita ever went and fought.”
He further said, “She was the wife of Maryada Purushottam, the ideal righteous man, and displayed a spirit of service. She was not a fighter. If she had been a fighter, she would have fought Ravana. Why was Ravana able to capture her and take her away?”
Khanna also dismissed producer Namit Malhotra’s explanation that the sequence drew inspiration from alternative versions of the epic rather than Valmiki’s account. He insisted that there was only one Ramayana, authored by sage Valmiki, and questioned whether filmmakers would make comparable changes to other religious scriptures.
The Shaktimaan actor also questioned whether commercial considerations surrounding the film’s reported Rs 4,000 crore budget should outweigh traditional narratives. He clarified that his objections were based on promotional material, audience responses and reviews, as he had not watched the film himself. He also raised concerns about the broader tendency to introduce personal interpretations into sacred texts such as the Ramayana and the Mahabharata.
More about the film
Directed by Tiwari, Ramayana: Rise of a Legend features Ranbir Kapoor as Rama, Sai Pallavi as Sita, Yash as Ravana and Ravie Dubey as Lakshman. The epic is being adapted into a two-part cinematic franchise.
The first instalment arrived in theatres on November 5. Sunny Deol appeared as Hanuman in a post-credits sequence, hinting at a more prominent role in the second film, which is scheduled to release in 2028.
